OFF is an academic gathering revolving around the recognised state of being off-focus.
Rather than renouncing knowledge, the blurred view encourages creative unease and the embrace of lateral questioning and permanent enquiry.
OFF collects random subjects and artefacts relating to architecture, urbanism and landscape, prividing material for debate.
MEMBERS
Elisa Bacilieri (UniRomaTre)
/ Federico Broggini (UniFe)
/ Silvio Cristiano (UniFi)
/ Matteo Cucciniello (UniRomaTre) / Fabrizio D’Angelo (UniRomaTre/UniFi)
/ Alessandro Delli Ponti (UniFe)
/ Silvia Farano (UniRomaTre)
/ Federico Marchese (Polito)
/ Ilaria Maurelli (UniRomaTre)
/ Emilia Nardella (UniRomaTre)
/ Sofia Nicoletti Altimari (UniRomaUno)
/ Giordana Panella (UniRomaTre)
/ Marco Ranzato (UniRomaTre)
/ Riccardo Ruggeri (Polito)
/ Valeria Volpe (UniRomaTre)
Instagram
Reframing spatial justice
2022-ongoing / Research - Roma Tre University / Lazio, Sicily, Veneto, Italy
Authors: Fabrizio D'Angelo, Marco Ranzato, Valeria Volpe (Roma Tre University) with Elisa Bacilieri, Silvia Farano, Federico Marchese, Ilaria Maurelli, Emilia Nardella, Sofia Nicoletti Altimari, Giordana Panella
Others: Marta De Marchi, Alessia Franzese, Luca Nicoletto, Maria Chiara Tosi (IUAV) / Vito Martelliano, Elena Bruno, Gabriella Vindigni, Alessandro Grasso (UNICT)
Progetti di Rilevante Interesse Nazionale (PRIN), Italian Ministry of University and Research
SPATIAL JUSTICE
How are projects funded by the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (PNRR) contributing to changing the conditions of justice and injustice across territories? In what ways will they erode, or instead deepen, social and ecological inequalities among subjects, places and contexts?
Starting from these questions, the PRIN project Reframing Spatial Justice has been developing since 2023 a qualitative and situated reflection on the mechanisms through which PNRR projects have “landed” in territories and on their capacity to respond to local needs. The three research units involved look at the Plan not only as a funding programme, but as an opportunity to read ongoing territorial transformations, questioning the relationship between public resources, spatial inequalities, environmental conditions and institutional capacities.
Although the structural shortcomings of a “plan without a plan” and of a “funding plan” were widely discussed from the outset (often traceable to a sum of projects and funds falling onto territories in a fragmented way), the research takes on the need to “stay within the mesh” of the PNRR. This means observing the Plan’s grey zones, getting close to the places where projects are carried out, understanding their effects, limits and possibilities, but also identifying actors, relationships and actions capable of steering the phases that will follow its conclusion.
From this perspective, the PNRR becomes a lens through which to read the geographies of spatial justice and injustice: where are resources concentrated, which territories are reached, which remain more weakly involved, what opportunities are produced and for whom? The research thus attempts to shift attention from the mere distribution of funding to the capacity of projects to concretely transform the social, ecological and spatial conditions of territories.
Within this framework, the Rome unit focuses its work on a territorial transect of roughly 80x20 kilometres, extending from the Municipality of Fiumicino on the Tyrrhenian coast, through the Municipality of Rome, to the inner areas of the Rieti province. The transect makes it possible to observe profoundly different contexts (coastal, metropolitan, peri-urban and inner) by relating seemingly separate interventions and bringing out continuities, discontinuities, concentrations and fractures in the distribution of PNRR projects, as well as the differing capacities of public bodies to secure funds, propose projects and carry them through to completion.
Four in-depth studies, in which the analysis scaled down to the level of individual projects, focused on the Municipality of Fiumicino, Municipio IV of Rome, the Municipality of Fonte Nuova and that of Poggio Mirteto. Here, projects are read in relation to the context in which they are embedded and questioned on their capacity to act on the “fair and equitable distribution in space of socially valued resources and the opportunities to use them”, according to the definition of spatial justice proposed by Edward Soja.
The interventions observed operate across very different dimensions, ranging from the provision of services, to infrastructure and energy efficiency works, to hydrogeological risk mitigation measures. Some operations regenerate existing spaces, others deliver new facilities, services or socio-technical devices, while others still propose actions on public space and mobility. What these interventions often share, however, is their punctual and fragmented character: single operations, weakly connected to one another, which risk producing no lasting territorial effects unless they are brought into relation with other projects, actors, practices and local needs.
Reframing Spatial Justice therefore chooses to insist on the need for a re-meshing (rimagliamento). The term refers to a critical and design-oriented operation of reweaving spatial and relational networks: between one intervention and another, between individual interventions and the context in which they are set, between funded resources and territorial needs, between institutional actors and local subjects. Re-meshing means attempting to stitch back together what the PNRR tends to produce separately, turning a constellation of punctual projects into possible post-PNRR territorial scenarios
Photo credits: Tommaso Mola Melegalli